Artificial intelligence skepticism in news production: The case of South Africa’s mainstream news organizations

This chapter demonstrates that the celebratory acceptance of artificial intelligence (AI) appropriation, popular in mainstream scholarly discourses of AI, is often colored by an emerging, strong pushback by skeptical journalists. Using the case of South African journalists, we make two broad but related arguments. First, we argue that skepticism about AI among journalists in South Africa should be linked to the broader debates about the future and purpose of journalism in post-apartheid South Africa. Second, we argue that journalists view themselves as a peculiar community with a specific role of serving democracy—a role that will not sync neatly with AI practices. This chapter contributes to debates on AI and news production practices in less-explored global South contexts.